Andrew Cunanan: Jonathan Trent
Gianni Versace: Robert Miano
Cara Wheeler: Stacey Dash
TV Reporter: Cerina Vincent
Harry Spalding: James C. Burns
Agent Johnson: Mike Wiseman
Agent Richman: Joseph Sikora
Agent Melville: Jay Jablonski
Store Clerk: Callard Harris
Landlord: Robert Fun
Caretaker: Omar Leyva
David Madsen: Landall Goolsby
Miami Bouncer: Michael Garvey
Mary Ann Cunanan: Shea Sica
Swedish Woman: Anne Underwood
Clerk #1: Antonio Scalfini
Minnesota Cop: Bob Rusch
Boy #1: Joe Mahon
Boy #2: Brian Womack
Tom: Teaj Sanderson
VIP Bouncer: Umoja Butler
Drug Dealer: Makelaie Brown
Older Man: Peter Quintana
Gay Passerby: JD Brown
Phone Support Clerk: Daniel Utsinger
Hotel Clerk: Saul Herckis
Pawn Shop Man: Joey Abbene
Police Officer: Morgan Rogers
Reese: Nick Roberts
Spokesperson: Happy Richardson
Stan: Rod Britt
Walter: Faquizi Ifazi Brahimi
Gay Reporter: Marc Ambrose
Tony: Jack Kennedy
Jules: James Clark
Danny Acton: Dave Florek
French Waiter: Faquizi Brahimi
Modesto: Buzz Belmondo
Model: Ray Kelsey
VIP Bouncer: Umoja Bultler
Edward Swift: Craig Chapman
Jeffrey Trall: Jeff Hartley
Lee Miglin: Howard Ferguson-Woitzman
Laughing Cop: Abe Frederick
James McNeil: Tyler McGauley